EU’s Trade Agenda: Broken Promises Revealed – Prepare to Be Shocked!

Title: Exploring European Trade Deals and Estonia’s Approach to Frozen Russian Assets

Introduction

In this article, we delve into the recent developments in European trade deals and Estonia’s unique approach to spending frozen Russian assets. We analyze the challenges faced by the European Union (EU) in striking trade deals with partners who have different views, particularly in the case of developing countries. Additionally, we explore Estonia’s decision to take matters into its own hands by proposing legislation to use frozen Russian assets to offset specific damages caused by Russia.

European Trade Deals: A Lackluster Record

The EU’s trade deals have faced various obstacles, particularly when it comes to negotiating with partners who hold different views or interests. For instance, while a trade agreement with New Zealand was successfully finalized, other deals with developing countries, such as Kenya and Mexico, remain unsigned. The EU’s requests for binding commitments to protect the rainforest from Mercosur bloc members (Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, and Paraguay) have also proved challenging.

One of the key problems lies in the need to compromise on certain aspects of the agreements to accommodate partners’ concerns. The EU has often had to leave aside investments, services, and accept less ambitious labor and sustainable development commitments. This issue highlights the difficulty of finding a balance between diverse perspectives and maintaining EU standards.

Negotiations with Australia and Latin America

The EU’s trade commissioner, Valdis Dombrovskis, expressed optimism about the ongoing negotiations with Australia, indicating that a deal could be reached by mid-July. Australia is seen as a “like-minded partner” by the EU, and the agreement is expected to be significant for both parties.

Another important step for the EU is the upcoming summit with Latin America and the Caribbean, particularly in relation to the Mercosur bloc. While talks have turned sour due to the EU’s requests for binding commitments to protect the rainforest, the EU aims to overcome these challenges and proceed with the agreement. However, gaining the approval of member states remains a significant hurdle, with some countries expressing concerns about cheap beef imports and environmental implications.

Estonia’s Approach to Frozen Russian Assets

In response to Russia’s war on Ukraine, EU member states froze over €224 billion in Russian assets through sanctions. The debate surrounding the legality and usage of these frozen assets has been ongoing, with some countries eager to find a way to use them to help rebuild Ukraine, while others cite legal hurdles and financial risks.

In a bold move, Estonia has decided to take matters into its own hands by proposing legislation that allows the country to use the frozen Russian assets to offset specific damages caused by Russia. The Estonian government aims to charge those sanctioned for their state’s crimes and show that their national law permits such actions. They seek to set an example for other EU member states to follow.

Key Considerations and Limitations

It’s important to note that Estonia’s approach is limited in scope. They target only frozen assets belonging to sanctioned Russian individuals and entities, which amount to around €50 million. This is significantly lower than the frozen assets held by the Russian central bank in the EU, which are valued at over €200 billion. The utilization of these assets could have broader implications for global markets.

Estonia’s willingness to take action demonstrates their determination to hold Russia accountable and their belief that their approach can set a precedent for other EU member states. They emphasize the need to find a solution collectively and move forward as a united European Union.

Conclusion

The EU’s recent challenges with trade deals highlight the complexities of navigating diverse perspectives and interests. While agreements with like-minded partners may be easier to achieve, negotiations with developing countries and balancing competing concerns can prove difficult.

Estonia’s decision to propose legislation to utilize frozen Russian assets underlines their commitment to seeking justice and finding solutions to complex international issues. While their approach may have limitations in terms of scope, Estonia intends to set an example for other EU member states to follow.

Overall, the EU’s trade landscape and Estonia’s innovative approach provide valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities faced by the region. As negotiations continue and countries explore alternative approaches, it remains to be seen how these initiatives will shape future trade agreements and international relations.

—————————————————-

This article is an on-site version of our Europe Express newsletter. register here to receive the newsletter directly in your inbox every day of the week and on Saturday morning

Good morning. Today our trade correspondent assesses the EU’s recent lackluster record in striking trade deals, while I hear how Estonia seeks to resolve the European debate over spending frozen Russian assets by simply doing so herself.

barter

Negotiations on a trade deal with Australia are expected to be finalized within weeks, the EU’s trade commissioner told a news conference yesterday to re-announce a deal struck a year ago with New Zealand. Zeeland.

But while Valdis Dombrovskis hailed the pact with a “like-minded partner”, a list of other trade talks remains stuck, writing Andy Bounds.

Context: the big problem for the EU is the signature deals with partners with different views, i.e. developing countries. He recently landed one with Kenya only by leaving aside investments, services and accepting less ambitious labor and sustainable development commitments than those with New Zealand.

A 2018 deal with Mexico remains unsigned, while talks with Mercosur bloc turn sour on the EU’s requests for Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay (its members) to sign binding commitments to protect the rainforest after reaching an agreement.

Yesterday’s endorsement ceremony seemed staged to give Sweden something to announce after a six-month presidency devoted to liberalizing trade with a frustrating outcome.

Johan Forssell, Sweden’s trade minister, said the EU was in a better position than six months ago. “I think we’ve succeeded in what we said we were going to do to give this important theme a big boost,” he said.

Dombrovskis said the “final game” with Australia was close, with a deal possible by mid-July. He added that an upcoming EU summit with Latin America and the Caribbean was an “important step for the EU agreement with Mercosur”.

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, whose election last year gave EU officials hope for a new start in trade talks, however, said he was considering an EU request to associate agreeing additional climate and sustainability commitments. a threat”.

EU officials say that behind closed doors, Brazil’s rhetoric is more muted. But even if Mercosur is signed, the EU must struggle to obtain the approval of member states. Austrian and Dutch parliaments have passed resolutions against the deal, while France is skeptical. Fear of cheap beef imports is as big a factor as their love of the Amazon.

When the FT asked free trade champion Forssell what he had learned in leading the EU towards a more open market, he laughed and skirted the question.

Chart of the day: Between a rock and a hard border

You see a snapshot of an interactive chart. This is probably because you are offline or JavaScript is disabled in your browser.

The British territory of Gibraltar, with its 34,000 inhabitants, is heavily dependent on Spanish workers. But the probable victory of the conservative People’s Party (PP) in Spain upcoming election could undermine negotiations for a post-Brexit deal on the status of the territory, writing Barney Jopson.

Test cases

As EU governments, the European Commission and the European Central Bank vie for the the legality of spending frozen Russian assets, Estonia decided it was done pending a decision. They’ll just snap and do it themselves.

Background: In response to Russia’s war on Ukraine, EU member states froze more than €224 billion in Russian assets as a result of sanctions. Many countries want find a way to use it to help rebuild Ukraine. Others say There is too many legal hurdles and financial risks to do so.

The Estonian government is expected to propose legislation this fall to use the assets to offset specific damages caused by Russia, effectively charging those sanctioned for their state’s crimes.

“We all decided together that Russia should pay. . . Now the question is about the legal solution,” Estonian Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna said. “We have to move forward as a European Union. . . What Estonia offers at the national level is this process. And this is an example for everyone.

Estonia’s thought is simple: Tired of hearing that various legal approaches will not workthey want to show that under their national law, it is possible, and that afterwards, the world continues to turn.

A court will examine each claim, and those whose property is seized will have the opportunity to seek redress.

The two caveats are that Tallinn only targets frozen assets belonging to sanctioned Russian individuals and entities, which in Estonia is only around 50 million euros. This is a far cry from the main debate over Russian central bank assets frozen in the EU. They are worth more than 200 billion euros according to the European Commission, and their use could have far greater implications for global markets.

“Most of the things we did together in the EU were first seen as a bad idea,” Tsahkna said. “In Estonia we have bad weather, but we are very optimistic.”

What to watch today

1. The European Commission presents digital euro proposal.

2. Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas and Finnish Prime Minister Petteri Orpo meet EU leaders in Brussels.

3. French President Emmanuel Macron receives NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg in Paris.

Now read these

Newsletters recommended for you

Britain after Brexit – Keep up to date with the latest developments as the UK economy adjusts to life outside the EU. Register here

Trade secrets — Essential reading on the evolution of international trade and globalization. Register here

Do you like Europe Express? register here to receive it directly in your inbox every working day at 7:00 a.m. CET and on Saturday at noon CET. Let us know what you think, we love to hear from you: europe.express@ft.com. Keep up to date with the latest European stories @FT Europe

—————————————————-