The Intricacies of Online Privacy: Your Face Belongs to Us

Introduction: Uncovering the Hidden Perils of the Internet

With the advent of social media and the ever-expanding online world, our lives have become interconnected like never before. However, the anonymity and freedom that the internet provides can also expose us to unforeseen risks. In the thought-provoking book, “Your Face Belongs to Us: A Secret Startup’s Search to End Privacy as We Know It” by Kashmir Hill, the author delves into the unsettling reality of facial recognition technology and its impact on personal privacy.

Exploitation Knows No Boundaries

Over 15 years on Facebook, the protagonist befriended numerous women, unaware of the potential consequences that lay beneath these digital connections. A chance encounter with a near-stranger at a club while on vacation initiated a Facebook friendship that would later unravel a hidden secret. This newfound friend had a past in pornography, with her appearance drastically altered from her online persona to her past on-screen identity.

But this was just the tip of the iceberg. Further investigation by the protagonist revealed a string of shocking discoveries. A friend had unknowingly uploaded nude photos to a Reddit community, while another acquaintance participated in the World Naked Bike Ride, unknowingly exposing herself to a faceless audience. Even the innocent act of renting a room resulted in an unwitting association with revenge porn due to the previous occupant’s actions. The victims’ identities were concealed in these images until the emergence of a search tool that organized the internet by recognizing faces.

The Challenge of Online Image Removal

Removing explicit photos of oneself from the internet is no easy feat. While search engines like Google offer request forms to remove content by name, the more daunting task is eradicating images through a search by face. This is where PimEyes, a controversial service, comes into play. PimEyes’ “PROtect plan” promised to not only help individuals unearth photos they were unaware of but also provided support in removing them from various sites.

However, one victim of unfortunate photos referred to the service as “professional sextortion.” Despite its claims to uphold privacy laws, PimEyes lacked technical controls to prevent unauthorized uploads. The service intended for self-image searches, became an unwarranted tool for invading others’ privacy.

Risking it All: Unawareness on the Internet

In today’s digital landscape, many individuals are oblivious to the possibilities and perils that exist online. From platforms like Onlyfans that tout anonymity to websites such as Ashley Madison that enable discreet connections, users expose themselves unknowingly by displaying their faces. These individuals fail to grasp the risks associated with such actions.

The protagonist, David, pondered whether he should anonymously inform his friends about the availability of these compromising photos. Yet, he feared the potential harm it could cause, outweighing the good he hoped to achieve. The pervasive danger of the internet resides in the fact that knowledge can be both empowering and harmful, depending on the circumstances.

PimEyes: Beyond a Startup

Originally created by a group of hackers, PimEyes caught the attention of a security studies professor based in Tbilisi, Georgia. In 2021, he purchased the service, firmly believing that facial recognition technology should be accessible to all. He compared the potential ban on this technology to the prohibition of alcohol in the United States in the 1920s, suggesting that it would be equally ineffective.

Although the service boasted privacy protection through its checkbox disclaimers, there were no technical safeguards preventing unauthorized image uploads. This highlighted the contradiction between claims of adhering to European privacy laws and the reality of the service’s operations.

The Deceptive Facade of Ignorance

In an attempt to shield himself from the disturbing reality of his digital footprint, David refrained from uploading his own photo to PimEyes. His rationale behind this decision was best encapsulated in the saying, “ignorance is bliss.” The fear of uncovering potentially damaging images outweighed any potential benefit he sought from the service.

Conclusion: Navigating the Complexities of Online Privacy

The book, “Your Face Belongs to Us: A Secret Startup’s Search to End Privacy as We Know It,” offers a chilling account of the implications of facial recognition technology. Through the protagonist’s journey, we gain insight into the unexpected consequences of online connections and the vulnerabilities that accompany them.

The digital age has revolutionized the way we interact, but we must tread carefully to protect our privacy and personal boundaries. The need for vigilance and awareness becomes increasingly crucial as technology advances and invades our lives. Ultimately, it is up to us to navigate the intricacies of the internet and determine how much of ourselves we are willing to expose.

---

From the book Your Face Belongs to Us: A Secret Startup’s Search to End Privacy as We Know It by Kashmir Hill. Copyright © 2023 by Kashmir Hill.
Published by Random House, an imprint and division of Penguin Random House LLC. All rights reserved.

---

If you buy something using links in our stories, we may earn a commission. This helps support our journalism.
Learn more.

Over 15 years on Facebook, he had befriended hundreds of women. The first person to hit him was a near-stranger he had once met at a club while he was on vacation. They became friends on Facebook and never interacted again. “It turned out that she filmed pornography at some point in her life,” she said. “She Now she is brunette, but in porn she was blonde.”

Then she discovered more: A friend had posted nude photos to a Reddit community called Gone Wild, a place meant to anonymously collect body compliments. There were topless photos of an acquaintance who had participated in the World Naked Bike Ride. A woman who had requested a room he had rented once took nude selfies on a revenge porn website. The women’s names were not attached to the photos. They had remained hidden until a search tool appeared that organized the Internet by faces.

It can be extremely difficult to remove naked photos of yourself from the Internet. Search engines like Google have free request forms to remove them from a search by name, but what about a search by face? That, of course, was a service PimEyes provided, for a price. PimEyes’ “PROtect plan” started at around $80 per month. It was advertised as a way to find photos you didn’t know about, with “dedicated support” to help remove them from the sites where they appeared, but one woman trying to remove unfortunate photos from the service called it professional sextortion. .

Originally created in Poland by a couple of hacker types, PimEyes was purchased in 2021 for an undisclosed amount by a security studies professor based in Tbilisi, Georgia. The professor told me that he believed that facial recognition technology, now that it exists and is not going away, should be accessible to everyone. A ban on this technology would be as effective, he said, as the prohibition of alcohol in the United States in the 1920s. Those who paid attention to a box to click before searching would see that it is supposed to that you only have to look for your own face. Searching for other people without their consent, the professor claimed, was a violation of European privacy laws. However, the site had no technical controls to ensure that a person could only upload their own photo for a search.

Many people on the Internet today don’t realize what is possible. People on Onlyfans, Ashley Madison, Searching, and other websites that cultivate anonymity hide their names but expose their faces, not realizing the risk involved in doing so. David wondered if he should tell his friends, anonymously, that these photos were available and could be found thanks to new technology, but he worried that they would be scared and that he would do more harm than good.

He had never uploaded his own face to PimEyes, as was the supposed purpose of the service, because he didn’t want to know what photos would appear. “Ignorance is bliss,” she said.

---

From the book Your Face Belongs to Us: A Secret Startup’s Search to End Privacy as We Know It by Kashmir Hill. Copyright © 2023 by Kashmir Hill. Published by Random House, an imprint and division of Penguin Random House LLC. All rights reserved.

---

If you buy something using links in our stories, we may earn a commission. This helps support our journalism. Learn more.