Title: Commercial Real Estate: Navigating Uncertain Times
Introduction:
The commercial real estate (CRE) market has been significantly impacted by the ongoing economic uncertainties. While some segments have shown resilience, others are experiencing distress. This article explores the current state of the CRE market, focusing on the challenges faced by various sectors and the potential implications for the broader economy.
Understanding the Commercial Real Estate Landscape:
1. A Tale of Two Markets:
– The divergence between prime and less desirable properties is evident in the CRE market.
– Prime properties continue to attract tenants and investors, while older or less desirable buildings face increasing distress.
– Notably, New York City’s office market showcases this disparity, with significant variations in occupancy rates and rent levels.
2. Distressed Properties:
– The number of distressed CRE assets has increased, albeit from a relatively small base.
– MSCI Real Assets reports a 10% rise in distressed CRE assets in the first quarter of 2023.
– However, the overall volume of distressed properties remains manageable compared to the total market.
3. Risk Factors:
– The CRE market’s stability is contingent on a robust economic backdrop.
– Low unemployment rates, wage growth, and high corporate profits have supported rental income and debt servicing.
– However, a weakening job market and falling incomes could lead to declining rental income and further difficulties in meeting debt obligations.
The Impact of Current Economic Uncertainties on Commercial Real Estate:
1. Refinancing Challenges:
– The ongoing refinancing cycle poses challenges for CRE owners.
– Higher interest rates and stricter lending conditions could make it harder to refinance debt, leading to potential distress.
2. Uneased Interest Rates:
– Rising interest rates contribute to increasing borrowing costs for CRE investors.
– While rates have remained low historically, their recent upward trend may impact the affordability of commercial real estate.
3. Potential Contagion Effects:
– A prolonged economic downturn, such as a recession, could exacerbate the existing challenges in the CRE market.
– A crisis market could emerge, impacting not only distressed properties but also prime assets, creating a broader contagion effect.
Navigating the Uncertainties:
1. Thorough Due Diligence:
– In this uncertain market environment, thorough due diligence is crucial for investors.
– Identifying properties with strong fundamentals, tenants, and income streams is essential for mitigating risks.
2. Diversification and Quality:
– Investing in a diversified portfolio of commercial properties can help reduce exposure to specific sectors or locations that are more vulnerable.
– Focusing on high-quality assets that attract desirable tenants can provide stability during volatile market conditions.
3. Adaptation and Innovation:
– Property owners and managers must adapt to changing market dynamics.
– This may involve repositioning assets, renovating or upgrading properties, and exploring innovative leasing strategies.
Conclusion:
The current state of the commercial real estate market presents a mixed picture, with some segments thriving while others face distress. The resilience of prime properties and their ability to attract tenants and investors provide hope amidst the uncertainty. However, challenges persist, and the potential for contagion effects looms if the economic backdrop deteriorates. Thorough due diligence, diversification, and adaptation are key strategies for navigating these uncertainties and positioning oneself for success in the commercial real estate market.
Summary:
Commercial real estate (CRE) is experiencing a divergence between prime and less desirable properties. While some segments continue to perform well, others are facing increasing distress. The economic uncertainties, including rising interest rates and refinancing challenges, pose risks to the stability of the market. Thorough due diligence, diversification, and adaptation are essential for navigating this uncertain landscape. Despite the challenges, the CRE market presents opportunities for savvy investors who carefully evaluate and select high-quality assets.
—————————————————-
| Article | Link |
|---|---|
| UK Artful Impressions | Premiere Etsy Store |
| Sponsored Content | View |
| 90’s Rock Band Review | View |
| Ted Lasso’s MacBook Guide | View |
| Nature’s Secret to More Energy | View |
| Ancient Recipe for Weight Loss | View |
| MacBook Air i3 vs i5 | View |
| You Need a VPN in 2023 – Liberty Shield | View |
Receive free market updates
We will send you a myFT Daily Digest email rounding last Markets news every morning.
This article is an in-place version of our Unhedged newsletter. Registration Here to receive the newsletter directly in your inbox every day of the week
Good morning. This economy continues to hold surprises. Durable goods new orders rebounded 1.7% in May, despite gloomy manufacturing surveys and well above inflation. Two-year yields jumped on the news. Is anything still preventing the Fed from raising rates? Email us: robert.armstrong@ft.com AND ethan.wu@ft.com.
Commercial real estate: content, for now
Where are we in the downward spiral of commercial real estate? It is hard to say. CRE is opaque. Transaction volumes are so low that it’s hard to know for sure what buildings are worth. Higher interest rates take time to make an impact. Lease negotiations take place behind closed doors. Two recent Financial Times articles highlight the difficulty. The first, from Sunday, it sounded terrible:
One broker estimated that only the wealthiest 10% of office buildings in New York were not in trouble, both in terms of debt levels and occupancy. “I think we are at the forefront of forced selling,” this person said. . .
Offices aren’t the only sector under pressure. Some rental apartment properties, seen as a safe bet during the coronavirus pandemic, are also struggling.
In Houston, Applesway Investment Group bought four aging apartment complexes with nearly $230 million in floating-rate debt starting in 2021, hoping it could raise rents. But he couldn’t cover his payments after rates went up. Lender Arbor Realty Trust foreclosed on the properties in April.
The other, released on Monday, it struck a hopeful note:
New York City’s largest office owner has agreed to sell a stake in a prominent tower that gives [the building] a $2 billion valuation, a modest markdown from its previous price that was a relief in a commercial real estate market plagued by vacancy.
SL Green will sell its 49.9% stake in Manhattan’s 245 Park Avenue building to Japan’s Mori Trust. . .
Harrison Sitomer, chief investment officer at SL Green, said its Park Avenue properties were still reporting robust rents despite the broader market turmoil. . .
“There’s been a noticeable shift in momentum for groups looking to find products in New York,” he said, citing growing calls for potential partners.
Shares of SL Green, which had lost two-thirds of their value since the start of the pandemic, gained nearly 30% this week on the news. Other big-city office REITs like Boston Properties and Vornado have also received a sympathetic boost.
However, 245 Park sale may not be representative. The structure, a few steps from Grand Central Station, is located in a privileged position. And the dispersion of performance – in asset prices, rents, vacancy and delinquencies – between the top of the market and the middle or bottom appears to be increasing. For Class C offices, the worst type, renovation is too expensive and rent cuts alone won’t stimulate demand, notes Kiran Raichura, real estate economist at Capital Economics. JLL, a broker, estimates that 30 percent of office buildings account for 90 percent of total vacancies in the US market, a sort of Pareto principle for cubic cubicles.
The fork in the market is visible in commercial mortgage-backed stocks, where triple B (low investment grade) spreads have skyrocketed again near the Covid highs, even as triple A spreads remain tight. Investors want a big discount for holding lower quality assets:
Fortunately, the slice of the market that is in trouble is small. Triple-A CMBSs, which have not seen their spreads explode, make up 87% of the market, according to Ned Davis Research. In the wider CRE world, the number of distressed properties (in default or very close to it) is small compared to the total market. Distressed CRE assets tracked by MSCI Real Assets rose 10% in the first three months of 2023, to a total of $64 billion. For example, US banks hold $2.9 trillion in CRE loans (and non-banks also hold a lot of CRE debt).
While the numbers are small now, they will increase, at least a little. MSCI classifies an additional $155 billion in commercial property as in “potential danger,” which includes defaulted or forbearing assets.
For office buildings, rescue numbers are already increasing rapidly. While most default rates for CMBS-packed housing debt are slightly higher than they were before the pandemic, they appear broadly stable. In office buildings, on the other hand, there is a clear upward trend. See the blue line here:
In summary: The CRE market is very bifurcated. The best properties still attract good tenants and willing investors. In older, less desirable buildings, however, signs of distress are growing. Fortunately, the problem is so far contained to a small slice of the total market.
Keep in mind, however, that stress has remained contained in part due to a robust economic backdrop. The unemployment rate is at an all-time low of 3.7%, wage growth is strong and corporate profits remain very high compared to history. If the job market deteriorates and incomes fall, rental income will decline and debt payments will become even more difficult to meet. This graph from Moody’s shows how sensitive CRE revenues are to labor market conditions. Note the coordinated dips between the decline in employment and rental income:
Further difficulties are likely inevitable, if only because the refinancing cycle continues and rates look set to stay high for a while. But a recession would turn a small problem into a pervasive problem and a bifurcated market into a crisis market. (Wu & Armstrong)
A good read
How does cryptocurrency earn they are spent (hat tip Tyler Cowen).
FT podcasts without coverage
Can’t get enough of Unhedged? Listen Our new podcasts, hosted by Ethan Wu and Katie Martin, for a 15-minute dive into the latest market news and financial headlines, twice a week. Stay updated on past editions of the newsletter Here.
Newsletters recommended for you
—————————————————-