How to Navigate Honoring an Abusive Parent: Exploring the Complexities
The author of the original piece shares their experience as the adult son of an explosive, intolerant, and narcissistic father. They endured years of beatings, constant yelling, and harsh treatment, which left them terrified. Despite witnessing their father abuse their siblings as well, the abuse was mostly directed at the author. However, in their father’s last months, he admitted to his cruel treatment and left a voicemail expressing his desire to apologize.
Now, as the funeral approaches, the author faces a dilemma. Their siblings, who took care of their father until his death, are organizing a tribute in his memory. However, some relatives express concern that the author’s presence may upset the children. His father’s sister discourages him from attending, seemingly more out of fear of his presence than concern for his well-being. The author grapples with how to honor or commemorate an abuser and wonders how they can be present with their wife and children at the family’s loyal tribute.
The ethicist advises that the author cannot improve their relationships with their father’s family if they continue to view the author’s anger as the problem rather than acknowledging the abuse. They suggest addressing this issue to have healthier relationships. However, they doubt that the funeral monument is the appropriate place to correct this dynamic. Nonetheless, the author can still introduce themselves at the tribute to gain insights into the family’s perspectives and learn more about their own spouse and children.
The ethicist also proposes writing an account of the abuse, mentioning the father’s admission of guilt, and sharing it with the entire family. This could bring awareness to those who may not have known the full extent of the abuse or prompt others to confront their denial and express sympathy. Regardless of the responses received, the author will have found their own way to remember the complicated and disturbing truth.
Additional Piece: Unraveling the Layers of Honoring an Abuser
The experience of grappling with how to honor and commemorate an abusive parent is one that many individuals face. It is a deeply personal and complex journey that requires careful consideration of one’s own emotions and values. In this additional piece, we will delve deeper into the subject matter, exploring the layers of emotions, societal expectations, and the importance of personal healing in navigating this dilemma.
1. Unpacking the Emotional Complexity:
Honoring an abusive parent often stirs up a whirlwind of emotions within the survivor. There may be a conflicted mix of anger, grief, relief, guilt, and even love. It is essential to acknowledge and validate these feelings while also prioritizing one’s own healing and well-being. This process may involve therapy, self-reflection, and setting healthy boundaries with the family.
2. Challenging Societal Expectations:
Society often places immense value on familial bonds and the idea of honoring parents. However, blindly adhering to these expectations can invalidate the experiences of those who have suffered abuse. It is crucial to challenge and redefine societal norms surrounding family dynamics. Honoring an abusive parent should never come at the expense of one’s mental health.
3. Recognizing the Complexity of Human Beings:
Human beings are complex, and abusive individuals can still exhibit acts of generosity and support. It is essential to acknowledge and validate these positive aspects while keeping in mind the larger context of the abuse. The author mentions their father’s financial generosity and support for education, but these actions do not negate the harm caused by the abuse.
4. Finding Healing and Closure:
Honoring an abusive parent does not mean condoning or excusing their behavior. Instead, it can be an opportunity for personal healing and closure. By attending the tribute and witnessing the family’s perspective, the author may gain insights into their own journey and find validation for their experiences. It is crucial to prioritize self-care and surround oneself with a support system during this process.
Conclusion:
Navigating the complexities of honoring an abusive parent is a deeply personal journey that requires careful consideration of one’s emotions, values, and well-being. It is essential to challenge societal expectations, seek healing and closure, and prioritize personal growth. By sharing one’s story and finding their own way to remember the truth, survivors can reclaim their narratives and pave a path towards healing and empowerment.
Summary:
The original piece explores the author’s experience as the adult son of an abusive father and their dilemma of attending their father’s tribute while acknowledging the abuse they endured. The ethicist advises addressing the family’s denial and sharing the truth, while also attending the tribute for personal growth and understanding. The additional piece delves deeper into the emotional complexity, societal expectations, recognizing human complexity, and finding healing and closure when honoring an abusive parent. It emphasizes the importance of prioritizing one’s well-being and challenging societal norms to navigate this intricate journey.
—————————————————-
| Article | Link |
|---|---|
| UK Artful Impressions | Premiere Etsy Store |
| Sponsored Content | View |
| 90’s Rock Band Review | View |
| Ted Lasso’s MacBook Guide | View |
| Nature’s Secret to More Energy | View |
| Ancient Recipe for Weight Loss | View |
| MacBook Air i3 vs i5 | View |
| You Need a VPN in 2023 – Liberty Shield | View |
I am the adult son of an explosive, intolerant and narcissistic father, who found gratification in his harsh treatment of me during my childhood and adolescence. I was terrified of his beatings and his constant yelling. Over time, he settled into an easy contempt for me. Although I also saw him abuse my brothers, my father focused his abuse on me, his firstborn.
He died a few months ago. In their later years, I stepped out of estrangement to help my siblings understand their complicated medical situations. In his last months, he admitted to his sister and one of my brothers his cruel treatment of me. After years of denying and justifying his abuse, he left me his last words recorded in a voicemail message, saying, “I will never get over my fight to apologize to you.”
My father was financially generous and supported our education, our homes, and our families. My brothers took care of him until the end and now they are organizing a tribute in his memory, “for the children”. As the funeral approached, a brother of mine expressed concern that I might “get triggered” and upset the children. My father’s prim octogenarian sister warned me not to attend, apparently more out of fear of my presence than for my well-being. These relatives fear the truth of my experience, which would threaten their facade and their denial of their cruelty, all of which are in the service of “good family” decorum.
I am grateful for the love and support of my wife and children, and I want to be with them at the funeral. Going to the monument to witness tradition and mythology will help me understand the family. How can I be present with my wife and children at my family’s loyal tribute to my abusive father? How can you honor or commemorate an abuser? The silence around child abuse is deafening. — Name withheld
From the ethicist:
It seems as if part of what worries her about the upcoming ceremony is that her relatives have not fully acknowledged the reality of what she experienced. You cannot improve your relationships with the rest of your father’s family as long as they treat your anger, rather than his abuse, as the problem. This will need to be addressed if you want to have decent relationships with them.
But I doubt you can correct that at the monument. As his story suggests, speaking openly about the abuse will be seen as reflecting not on your father but on you. I’d introduce myself anyway, if you can stand it. There is a good chance that you, as you say, will learn enlightening things about family and its perspectives, as well as your wife and children. You might also consider writing an account of what happened to you, mentioning that your father ultimately accepted that he had wronged you, and sending it to your family as a whole. What you have to report will surely be news to some of them. Others may come to see that what happened was worse than they allowed themselves to admit. Some may even take on a dark story that they had downplayed and express sympathy. Regardless of how people respond, you will have found your own way of remembering a complicated and disturbing truth.
Thoughts? If you would like to share an answer to today’s dilemma with the ethicist and other subscribers in the next newsletter, please complete this form.
readers respond
The question in the previous column was from a reader who lived on Cape Cod and who was frustrated with people coming to the beach early in the morning to set up chairs, towels, and umbrellas in prime spots, only to leave them empty until later that day. the same day. He wrote: “Is an empty chair or blanket a real occupation? Do these phantom claims have any merit? Would anyone have the right to ignore such maneuvers by removing these chairs or blankets?
In its response, the Ethicist noted: “Your beach blanket buccaneers are…effectively privatizing what should be public. At the same time, moving other people’s things should not be done lightly. You probably want to make sure that their owners haven’t been away for an acceptable interval. Social conventions about claiming areas in these public settings are, of course, not precise. Half an hour or so seems like a good marker to me in most of these circumstances.” (Reread the full question and answer here.)
⬥
The ethicist is right, but 30 minutes is too little. My family usually hang out in the ocean or take long walks on the beach for over an hour before returning to our chairs and umbrella. If the owner is still at the beach enjoying it away from his belongings, I think it constitutes an acceptable use of the space. Half an hour is insufficient to make that determination. — dave
⬥
I am a local resident of a very popular beach holiday destination. My family and I move back and forth between the beach and our house throughout the day. It would be impractical and foolish to haul our stuff back and forth with us. Those who look at us badly are usually tourists. We welcome them, but we expect a little welcome in return. That includes respecting our local customs, part of which is leaving our chairs and other belongings on the beach. — christina
⬥
Cape Cod’s beaches are spacious, and I find it hard to believe that the bather could not find another suitable place. There are many legitimate reasons someone might arrive early to set up a spot, whether it’s a parent coming in before returning with young children, or someone claiming space for an older family member who needs to be close to the beach path. — nancy
⬥
I have probably frequented that Cape Cod beach myself. I wouldn’t even dream of touching someone else’s belongings. My idea is to treat empty chairs in the same way as occupied chairs. Someone made the effort to get up early, get everything out of the car, assemble the equipment and save space. If you want prime beach real estate, be willing to put in the same effort yourself. — Paula
⬥
like someone who He also lives on the beach, I never considered this to be a problem until the columnist did. Part of the culture of the beach is to let go and not worry as much as one normally does about trivial matters. For me, claiming beach real estate with empty chairs falls into this category, particularly when there is plenty of beach to go around. — malcolm
Thanks for being a subscriber
They want more? Read past columns of ethics.
If you enjoy what you are reading, please consider recommending it to others. can register here. Browse all of our subscriber-only newsletters here.
Do you have your own ethical dilemma? Write to the ethicist at ethical@nytimes.com.
—————————————————-